Uncovered prior art others missed
Identified key invalidating prior art after two previous search providers were unable to locate sufficiently relevant references.
The Challenge
A leading U.S. patent litigation firm represented a client facing patent infringement allegations. Two previous search firms had already conducted invalidity searches but failed to identify prior art capable of challenging the asserted patent claims.
With litigation underway, the firm needed a research partner capable of looking beyond conventional search approaches to uncover stronger technical evidence.
The Solution
We first analyzed the existing search results to understand where earlier efforts had fallen short. We identified overlooked technical concepts, expanded the search beyond conventional classifications and keywords, and developed new search strategies tailored to the patent’s claim language and underlying technology.
This approach uncovered several highly relevant prior art references that had been missed in previous searches. We also prepared detailed claim mapping charts linking each reference to the asserted claims, providing technical support for the firm’s invalidity arguments.
The success of this engagement led to an ongoing relationship. Since then, the firm has relied on Parola Analytics across numerous patent litigation and post-grant matters involving multinational corporations and emerging technology companies
Our impact
Our expertise in designing targeted search strategies for complex patent matters has enabled us to build long-term client relationships and become a trusted partner in patent litigation and post-grant research.
Need stronger prior art for a patent invalidity challenge?
When existing searches fall short, we develop tailored invalidity search strategies to uncover overlooked prior art and provide litigation-ready technical evidence.
The challenge
Finding prior art after previous searches failed.
Why it worked
Search strategy built around the patent, not a template.
We re-evaluated the technology, identified gaps in earlier search efforts, and developed a targeted strategy that uncovered previously overlooked references.
The outcome